20 November 2026, Friday, 0:47
Support
the website
Sim Sim,
Charter 97!
Categories

«We’ve seen this movie before»: George W. Bush Institute Director Points to Mistakes by the Trump Administration

«We’ve seen this movie before»: George W. Bush Institute Director Points to Mistakes by the Trump Administration
David Kramer

We must not fall for Lukashenka’s tricks.

The Democratic Party won a landslide victory in the congressional elections, winning both the House of Representatives and the Senate. What developments could now unfold within the Republican Party? Who could become the Republican nominee in the elections? Will U.S. policy toward Ukraine and Belarus change?

Charter97.org discussed these issues with David Kramer, former U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy and Human Rights, former director of Freedom House, and executive director of the George W. Bush Institute:

— I think we saw that voters wanted a change, and the main issue that voters cited for their ballot was the issue of affordability. The economy is the frequent top issue in US elections: it's what people are paying for food, for gas, and other things. This election proved to be no different.

But where this election was different were the next couple of issues. One is opposition to the war with Iran that President Trump started at the end of February, which has contributed to the problems with affordability, with higher gas and food prices. Then also there is an issue of corruption — there have been Americans who have voiced considerable concern about what they perceive to be matters of corruption involving the administration.

Those were the three top issues. The economy is always the number one issue in our elections. That proved to be the same. And I think voters also view the tariffs that President Trump has imposed as contributing to the economic difficulties.

It is not uncommon for presidents of one party to suffer electoral setbacks during what we call the midterm elections (these are in which the president is not up for election, but a third of the Senate and all of the House members are). And it is fairly common that the party that is in the White House suffers a setback. That was true here, but this was a considerable setback, and it will be interesting to see how the White House interprets this and follows it.

We saw the appointment of Stephen Miller as the new chief of staff, and that is an indication that the administration is prepared to take a tough stand toward the Democrats in the House and the Senate and not look for too much compromise, but at the same time they may find some issues in which they will need to.

— What kind of presidential candidate do you see from the Republican Party in 2028?

— The assumption has been that Vice President J.D. Vance would be the most likely Republican candidate. He came out the day after the midterm elections and blamed the war in Iran for the electoral defeat. That is an issue on which I think he will have difficulty persuading voters because he has been vice president since day one of President Trump's second term.

It also seemed to create some tension with President Trump, who last week pulled the vice president off of negotiations with Iran and has him now focused on domestic issues, investigation of fraud in various Democratic states, the way the White House describes it. So I think the standing of the vice president has taken a bit of a hit, and that raises a whole bunch of questions about who might enter the race.

The Secretary of State and National Security Advisor Marco Rubio has said he will not run if Vice President Vance runs, but his name is now being mentioned quite a bit. The soon-to-be former governor of Florida, Ron DeSantis, is mentioned by some people, and there may be others who will enter the race. But I think the expectation was that after the midterms, the vice president would be the leading candidate — he may well be, but it seems a little less certain than it was before.

— What do you think about Ted Cruz as a candidate?

— Ted Cruz is another name that has been mentioned. He was talked about as a possible presidential candidate on the Republican side. We'll have to see.

In the state of Texas, where Ted Cruz is from and where he is a senator, the voters decided to, as the expression goes, "vote blue" — and voted for Democrats almost throughout the entire ballot, including the senator replacing John Cornyn, the governor, lieutenant governor, the attorney general and others down the list. So it will be interesting to see what Cruz decides to do.

— You mention as the top issues on voters' minds affordability, the Iran war, corruption and tariffs. So Ukraine was not even in the top four. What do the midterm results mean for American support for Ukraine?

— In general, we can expect that the Democratic House and the Democratic Senate will take up legislation that will show strong US support for Ukraine. Overall, there has been strong bipartisan (Republicans and Democrats) support for Ukraine. But the House leadership has been reluctant to bring up the legislation. The same with the Senate leadership.

I think you will see less hesitation from both the new Speaker of the House, who will likely be Hakeem Jeffries from New York, and the new Senate majority leader, who will likely be Chuck Schumer (although Chris Van Hollen has also indicated he will run). I think you will see legislation in support of Ukraine fairly early on in 2027. That may include military assistance and tightening of sanctions.

The outgoing Congress did vote for the Lindsey Graham legislation that called for tighter sanctions on Russia and tariffs on the major importers of Russian energy. It passed by 86 to 11 in the US Senate and by a very sizable margin in the House as well.

— As you've mentioned, we have to expect new legislation soon. But then the next question is: what will the administration do with that legislation?

— And that's the big question, because President Trump signed the Lindsey Graham legislation but then issued a waiver and is not enforcing it. That'll be the question with the new Congress. Even though there will likely be votes in support of Ukraine, we may not see the administration implement whatever legislation is passed or possibly even veto the legislation. And then the question will be, do the House and the Senate have two-thirds majorities to override that veto? I do think you will see more statements in support of Ukraine from the new Congress and probably more criticism and scrutiny of the administration's approach toward Ukraine and pressure on Russia.

Just last week, there were negotiations in Abu Dhabi where I would argue that the agenda was backwards. Instead of being focused on ending the war, an immediate ceasefire, they were talking about post-war European security architecture. That's what the Russians want to talk about. I would argue that that needs to be reversed. You cannot talk about post-war European security until you have an end to the war that Russia started against Ukraine. I think there will be more scrutiny and criticism of the administration's approach to efforts to end the war.

— American military aid since Trump came to power in 2024 has plummeted to less than one percent to what it used to be. A hypothetical question, let's fast forward to 2027: the administration is still against, but there is a group of senators, ardent supporters of Ukraine who travel to Ukraine, make loud statements. How much difference their activity will make in the end?

— The president of the United States under our Constitution has significant powers and authority on foreign policy, and there are limits to what the Congress can do. As we saw with the Lindsey Graham legislation, Congress can pass the legislation, and the president can even sign it. But if there are waiver provisions in it, the president can then exercise those waivers or simply choose not to implement the legislation.

There have not been Global Magnitsky sanctions imposed anywhere, I believe, since the return of the Trump administration. A human rights report that the State Department is supposed to issue every year has not been released for 2026. There needs to be accountability for following the law as it has been laid out. And that human rights report is required of the administration.

There need to be efforts to try to pressure the administration to do what the Congress has voted for. But at the same time, the administration has a lot of authority over foreign policy issues, and that may remain a challenge in terms of following through on what the Congress approves.

— Lukashenka has been running essentially the same simple playbook after 2006 and after 2010 elections: rig the vote, take political prisoners hostage and then trade them for sanctions relief and détente. Today the US administration is playing exactly the same game with Lukashenka, while the Europeans try a different approach and hold the sanctions line. How should this problem be dealt with today?

— We have seen this movie before. It's like the movie «Groundhog Day», where you wake up and relive the same thing over and over.

On the one hand, I credit John Coale and the administration for securing the release of hundreds of political prisoners. But at the same time there have been new political prisoners who have been rounded up, arrested, and sent to prison. And even many of those who have been released from prison have been forced out of their own country, and sent into exile. So we should be careful about getting too excited and enthusiastic.

Moreover, we should always keep in mind that Lukashenka is undoing a bad thing that he should have never done in the first place. So he should not get much credit for putting people in prison for their political beliefs and their criticism and undoing that and letting them free, but then filling their prison slot with someone else.

So I think it is something where the administration needs to be careful, in particular about pressuring Lithuania and other countries who have maintained sanctions and made it difficult for Lukashenka to benefit economically. I think the administration should be careful about its own approach and trying to get too close to Lukashenka.

Lukashenka, we have to remember, not only stole the 2020 election and then launched a brutal crackdown against peaceful protesters, he then hijacked a civilian airliner in May of 2021 going from Athens to Vilnius. He weaponized migrants and refugees into other countries. He allowed Russia to use Belarusian territory to launch the full-scale invasion against Ukraine in February of 2022. So Lukashenka has a lot of blood on his hands, and we should be very careful about getting too close to him.

Moreover, as you indicate with your question, Lukashenka has been using these same moves for decades. He's been in power since 1994, and he knows how to play the game, playing Russia and the West off of each other. But he will always be dependent on Putin and Russia for staying in power. And we should not fall for his games and think that we can lure him away and have him join our camp. That is simply not possible.

Write your comment

Follow Charter97.org social media accounts

▲